Conseillers maritimes depuis 1989 · Montréal

Marine advisors since 1989 · Montréal

Hébert & Associés, Conseillers Maritimes Inc.

Buying a boat from a private seller: what a good contract of sale should contain

Boat sales can give rise to many disputes. Between two private individuals, there is often neither a dealer nor a notary to put the agreements in writing: the price is negotiated at the marina, the equipment is promised verbally, and the delivery date remains vague. A good contract of sale, detailed and adapted to the transaction, protects both parties and prevents many misunderstandings. Here is what our marine advisors put in it.

This article expands on one step of our guide Buying a used boat: the checks a marine advisor makes.

1.

The parties: the buyer, the seller and their right to sign

A contract of offer or sale must contain two blocks that are easy to spot: BUYER and SELLER. Each block gives the names and addresses of the persons who are part of it.

Natural persons. They must have the legal capacity to sign. For an international sale, it is strongly recommended that all signatories be of the legal age required, both where the buyer lives and where the seller lives. The name and address of each party must match an official document, such as a driver’s licence, and at least one piece of photo identification must be presented.

One detail matters for registration: in the documents of a boat already registered in Canada, or one that will be, initials in the buyer’s given names are not accepted. Pierre H. Lauzon will be refused; Pierre Lauzon or Pierre Henri Lauzon will be accepted.

Companies. When a company sells or buys, you must obtain in writing:

  • a search certificate from an official source, which confirms that the company exists and that its status is in order, and which names its directors. Each province has its own system, and the federal government has that of Corporations Canada;
  • a resolution of the company authorizing the signatory to sign the sale or purchase documents, with the signature made before a notary, a lawyer or a commissioner of oaths.

Family trusts and registered names. They are accepted for boats with a Pleasure Craft Licence only, not for registered boats. A family trust that already owns a registered boat can make only one more transaction: selling it. A registered name that belongs to a company can make all the normal transactions.

The dealer. A dealer who sells a boat that is new or has a Pleasure Craft Licence does not have to provide a search certificate or a resolution: they act in the normal course of business. If the boat is already registered in the dealer’s name, they must provide them. And when a dealer actually acts as a broker, without the boat in their inventory, the real seller is not the dealer: it is a private sale. Our marine note Parties to a contract: sale or offer goes over each case, including sellers from other countries.

2.

The price, the exchange and the deposit

A fair and real price. The selling price is a set sum of money. If it is unfair or fictitious, the sale could be considered a gift. The official registers accept a sale for “$1 and other good and valuable consideration,” but the parties then base their agreement on other private documents that detail that consideration. In an offer, the amount is only truly set once all of its clauses have been met.

A sale with exchange. If part of the price is paid by handing another boat over to the seller, it is a sale with exchange. Each registered boat must then have its own contract and its own official documents, even the boat given in exchange. One of our Cautionary tales shows what happens when the exchanged boat is never officially transferred: at the time of an accident, a buyer no longer knew from whom he had bought his boat.

The deposit. The deposit is a partial payment of the price, refundable in most cases; the wording of the offer may, however, limit that refund. As a precaution, it is placed in trust and not handed directly to the seller. It should be as small as possible, but must show that the buyer is serious.

  • For the seller, it is an assurance: if the buyer does not meet their obligations by the agreed date, the deposit could become the seller’s property as damages.
  • For the buyer, it is a safeguard: once their offer is accepted, no other offer takes precedence over it, even at a higher price, as long as the time limits set in the offer are running.

American brokers often insist on receiving 10% of the price before presenting an offer. Their habits and their forms do not oblige a Canadian buyer to adopt them automatically.

3.

The clauses that protect the buyer and the seller

A well-written offer to purchase sets out what must be done, by whom and by what date. Our advisors include at least these sections:

Clause What it provides
Inspection and survey Inspection in and out of the water, a mechanical check and a sea trial, to the buyer’s complete satisfaction
List of equipment What is sold with the boat; it is used when taking possession and in an insurance claim
Credit approval The sale depends on obtaining the loan; otherwise, a letter from the lender confirms it
Payment mechanics The creditors to be paid, such as banks, marinas and repairers, and the order of the payments
Additional documents Operating and maintenance manuals, past maintenance and repair invoices
Taking possession The place, in the water or not, delivery by truck
Holdback In the cold season, an amount kept in trust until the launch

The inspection clause deserves particular attention. If the buyer is not entirely satisfied, they must notify the seller according to the terms of the offer. The seller may then propose a solution; if they cannot, the offer may be cancelled. Our marine note Inspection and survey explains the marine surveyor’s report and the sea trial.

The holdback clause protects the buyer of a boat that could not be tested. An amount, usually between 3% and 10% of the price, stays in trust until the launch, in the presence of the seller and the buyer, before a deadline written into the contract. If problems arise, the buyer has a certain number of days, for example 10 days, to present the invoices or estimates of a recognized repairer. The marine advisor pays them directly, then hands the rest to the seller. When everything is in order, the buyer signs the “Authorization to disburse” form and the seller receives what is owed.

4.

Payment, documents and signature

Once the conditions of the offer are met, the balance is deposited with the marine advisor and held in trust. The money is first used to pay the debts and claims, directly to the creditors. The rest is paid to the seller as soon as the sale documents are signed, adequate insurance has been issued to the buyer and, for a boat registered in Canada, the sale has been entered in the Canadian Register of Vessels. Our marine note Selling price, payment and holdback details these steps.

The contract also sets out the documents to be gathered before the final payment:

  • in Canada, the relevant documents are already in the hands of the marine advisor;
  • in another country, the advisor has received a copy of all the documents signed by the seller. On some of them, the seller’s signature is made before a lawyer, a notary, a Notary Public or a commissioner of oaths of the country where it is affixed. The seller undertakes in writing to send the originals as soon as they receive their money, by an express courier that allows close tracking.

The contract also says to whom the balance is paid. Foreign brokers like to receive the balance of the price directly, which protects their commission. The wording can vary from one contract to another: every word matters.

Before signing

Three habits prevent most problems:

  1. give a copy of the contract or the offer to both parties at least 24 hours before signing;
  2. never sign a document “in blank” or incomplete;
  3. put in writing everything that was discussed and agreed, including the seller’s promises.

Your marine advisor drafts with you a contract that contains all the relevant details: the price, the terms of payment, the warranties and the special agreements. They also make sure that existing debts are settled and discharged as they should be. From the start, you can get an estimate of their fees. For your contract, write to one of our marine advisors or call us at (514) 985-6606. Our Private sales page says more.

Firm service

Private sales

Marine note

Inspection and survey

Firm resource

Cautionary tales

Talk to a marine advisor

Give yourself the best chance: call us!

Share

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *