Conseillers maritimes depuis 1989 · Montréal

Marine advisors since 1989 · Montréal

Hébert & Associés, Conseillers Maritimes Inc.

Note 7: Selling price, payment and holdback

Marine note 7 of 10, published by Hébert & Associés in specialized magazines.

A capped pen rests on a document file and a blank cheque slip inside a sailboat cabin.

Selling price

The amount of the selling price is a specific amount of money. It must be fair and real. If it is unfair or fictitious, the sale could be considered a gift. In the case of offers, the amount is usually really determined after all clauses of the offer have been resolved.

The official vessel registration systems accept a sale for “$1.00 and other valuable considerations.” However, for the parties, a sale of this kind is usually supported by other documents which detail the expression “… other considerations.”

If the sale or part of its value is paid by the buyer transferring another vessel to the seller, it’s a sale with a trade-in.

Any registered vessel must have its own contract and its own official documents even for a trade-in vessel.

Deposit in relation to a purchase offer

The deposit is a partial payment of the selling price, possibly refundable in most cases. The text of the offer may place constraints on this refund. For safety, the deposit is kept in a trust account and not directly handed to the seller. It will be the smallest possible amount but must demonstrate that the buyer is serious.

For the seller

The deposit makes the seller more comfortable. If the purchaser is not fulfilling his obligations such as inspecting the vessel, having a survey completed, paying the balance of the sale, etc. by a specific date, the deposit could become the property of the seller as damages.

For the buyer

It provides security for the buyer. Following the acceptance of the offer by the seller, no other offer may be accepted by the seller, even if another potential buyer offers a higher price, as long as the agreements of the accepted offer have not been completed within the specified time limit.

US brokers

US brokers often insist on collecting an amount of 10% of the selling price before they present the offer to the seller. If a broker in Florida is too insistent, saying Florida law requires the 10%, it is perhaps because he has not recently consulted the “Florida Yacht and Ship Brokers’ Act” or another law on the subject. American brokers are accustomed to working in a certain way, with their own forms, but this does not mean that Canadians have to automatically adhere to their habits.

Main clauses in a purchase offer

  • The INSPECTION AND EVALUATION clause of an offer covers the quality and the condition of the vessel and of her equipment following a survey in and out of the water, a mechanical inspection, a sea trial (water test), etc. The results must be to the full satisfaction of the buyer. This subject is covered in more detail in Marine note no. 8, Inspection and survey.
  • Description of the equipment sold with the vessel. This is a checklist used when taking possession and a useful aid should a claim be filed with an insurer.
  • Credit approval. This will be discussed in Marine note no. 9, Marine credit.
  • Mechanics of payment and money transfers. Is there any creditor to pay, bank, marinas, repairers?
  • Agreement to furnish additional requested documents such as operating and maintenance manuals, past maintenance and repair invoices, etc.
  • Place where possession is taken, in or out of the water, truck transportation, etc.

Payment for the vessel

When the purchase conditions have been met, the payment balance shall be provided to the marine advisor who will deposit it in a trust account. This money will be used to pay debts and claims and the remainder to the seller as soon as:

  • All sale documents have been signed
  • Sufficient insurance coverage has been issued for the buyer
  • In the case of Canadian registered vessels, the sale has been registered in the Canadian Register book

Debt due on the vessel

Debts will be paid directly to the creditors by the marine advisor upon receipt of a letter issued by them confirming the amounts due and the way they want to be paid. These payments are not handed to the seller or to the buyer, except in very rare cases.

The mortgage release process, in Canada and in other countries, is detailed in Marine note no. 9, Marine credit.

We have seen cases where a buyer had given his seller a draft for the amount of the sale. The debt due to the bank was higher than the selling price; the bank was refusing to release the vessel.

In another case, a buyer went directly to pay his seller’s bank debt before the sale had been completed. This poses a considerable danger. Should the seller become unable to sign (accident, death, no more time, etc.), what happens? The vessel is not yet officially sold to the buyer and the seller now has a “free and clear” vessel plus the money.

Other payments

Depending on the wording of the contract, the balance of final payment will be delivered either to the seller or to the broker. Foreign brokers, American or from other countries, like to receive the selling price balance directly. It is a protection for their commission. However, the wording of the contract may differ from one transaction to another. Each word is important.

Method of payment

Payments are made by way of a marine advisor cheque but, when the amounts are sizable, they are completed by bank drafts or by wire transfer (electronic funds transfers).

Wire transfers

They are fast, effective and safe. Also, a confirmation of completed transfer (date, hour, minute) is issued by the system in the few seconds following the arrival of the money at its destination.

If your marine advisor processes many marine transactions, his bank will have provided him the required tools allowing the electronic wire transfers from his own office. Hébert & Associés has been equipped with such a system since 2004.

The broker’s or seller’s bank will receive the money within two (2) to four (4) hours after the initiation of the transfer. (The cutoff time is 14:00 for transfers in Canada, on working days, and 13:00 for transfers between Canada and the USA, on working days in both countries.) Transfers in Europe sometimes take more than 48 hours.

Certified cheques or drafts in the United States

In the USA, the money transfer system between banks is slower than in Canada. If you pay with a certified cheque or draft, even if the draft is drawn on a US bank, it is very likely that the seller’s bank will “freeze” the cheque or draft for 10 days or more, delaying taking possession of the vessel and the delivery of necessary original documents.

Documents before the final payment

Canada

Relevant documents are already in the possession of the marine advisor.

Other countries

A copy of all documents signed by the seller has already been received by the marine advisor. On some documents, the signature of the seller will have been witnessed by a lawyer, a notary, a notary public or a commissioner for oaths authorized in the country where the documents are signed.

The seller has also confirmed, in writing, that after the receipt of his money, he will immediately forward the original of the requested documents to the marine advisor, by courier, FedEx, DHL or another carrier. The use of this type of shipping allows closer follow-up.

Holdback

Transactions completed in winter are the source of some concern to buyers unless the vessel is sitting under a warm sky. The vessel has not been tested in water. It could have been recently surveyed but most surveyors are reluctant to issue an opinion when the hull is too cold; there is a danger. They may not detect potential problems.

In many holdback situations, the sale is completed quickly but, often in the cold season, a certain amount of money is kept in trust until the launching in the water in the presence of the seller and the buyer. A deadline date is specified in the contract.

If problems arise at that time, the buyer will have a certain number of days (e.g., 10 days) to forward to the marine advisor invoices or estimates for repairs prepared by a known marine expert. The marine advisor will directly pay these invoices. The rest will be remitted to the seller without further delay.

In holdback situations, when everything is in order, the buyer faxes to the marine advisor the “Authorization for Disbursement” form and the seller gets his due immediately.

This article is a short summary of some of the topics to consider in relation to a vessel purchase, sale or financing.

Each transaction is a special case.

Talk to a marine advisor

Give yourself the best chance: call us!